Frequently Asked Questions for Medical Practitioners
-
To initiate a claim, the Injuries Resolution Board requires Claimants to ask their treating doctor to complete the Injuries Resolution Board Medical Assessment Form.
-
Please note no new medical examination is required and you can complete the report from your medical records if you so wish.
-
This report is used by the Injuries Resolution Board to form an initial view of the injuries suffered by the Claimant and also in the assessment of the claim. The Board will where required arrange a follow up medical examination/s, by a member/s of its panel of independent medical examiners.
-
Reasonable charges levied on the claimant for completing the form will form part of the assessment of the claim by the Injuries Resolution Board . The patient should pay for the completion of the form, and seek to recoup the cost through the final assessment.
Medical practitioners completing personal injury medical reports for the purposes of the Injuries Resolution Board's processes are advocating for the medical facts of the case.
Yes. If you receive a consultation request from an independent examining doctor the Injuries Resolution Board will undertake to pay a reasonable consultation fee when requested.
A final prognosis regarding a claimant’s injuries is critically important to the Injuries Resolution Board's assessment procedures and should be provided where possible. Where a final prognosis is not possible the reasons should be provided in the context of for example further specialist examination, time for recovery, further treatment etc. in order that the Injuries Resolution Board can consider how to proceed.
Medical practitioners should complete the Whiplash Associated Disorder (WAD) scale. Claimants should complete the Neck Disability Index (NDI) scale and Visual Analogue Scale for pain.
The Whiplash Associated Disorder (WAD) and Neck Disability Index (NDI) scales relate to neck injuries only. The Visual Analogue Scale (VAS) for pain can be used at the discretion of medical practitioners for any / all injuries. The Whiplash Associated Disorder (WAD), Neck Disability Index (NDI) and Visual Analogue Scale (VAS) for pain scales should be completed with reference to the position at the time of the medical examination i.e. not in terms of a claimant’s injuries as they e.g. first presented.
Medical Practitioners have recommended to the Injuries Resolution Board that claimants complete the Neck Disability Index (NDI) and Visual Analogue Scale (VAS) for pain after their physical examination e.g. in the waiting room afterwards. The completed information can then be interpreted by medical practitioners when finalising the relevant medical report.
Unless there is some specific reason for not doing so the fully completed Neck Disability Index (NDI) should be included with the medical report being submitted.
If training in the area of report completion and / or soft-tissue injuries is required medical practitioners should in the first instance approach their own medical professional / training bodies. The Injuries Resolution Board is working with medical professional / training bodies to assist with any appropriate training programmes they consider necessary. The Injuries Resolution Board continues to monitor matters in this area and will communicate on any relevant developments. If you have a specific factual query, please do contact us.
Medical practitioners should request of claimant medical examination attendees completion and signing of any forms required e.g. the Neck Disability Index (NDI) and Visual Analogue Scale (VAS). Any such signed documents may be used in the preparation and completion of relevant medical reports by medical practitioners. Such medical reports prepared for the purposes of the Injuries Resolution Board’s processes can be shared with e.g. Respondents and their insurers. Medical practitioners as is the case with any expert witness can be subpoenaed to give evidence in court however this only happens very infrequently.
ICD10 is the World Health Organisation system and it has designations for all injuries;
https://www.who.int/classifications/icd/icdonlineversions/en/
Medical practitioners should record first and foremost the ICD10 code relating to the most dominant of the claimant’s injuries. Other / multiple ICD10 codes can be input thereafter.
Yes, claimants do not need to have an ongoing injury in order to be successful with a compensation claim.
Medical practitioners should provide every explanation and assistance possible to claimants with literacy issues. In the absence of full understanding by a claimant of the medical examination or an inability to complete or sign required documentation as part of that examination this should be stated by the examining medical practitioner in the relevant medical report.
Minor claimants are represented when bringing a personal injury claim by a next friend (NF) usually a parent or guardian who will accompany the minor claimant to their Injuries Resolution Board medical examination. The Irish Medical Council (IMC) Guide to Professional Conduct and Ethics are relevant and apply to all personal injury claim medical examinations.
The accompanying adult / parent / guardian or both the accompanying adult / parent / guardian and the minor claimant if feasible should complete and sign the Neck Disability Index (NDI) and Visual Analogue Scale (VAS).
The Personal Injury Commission (PIC) in its first report, proposed the adoption of a standardised approach to the examination and reporting of these injuries. Whiplash Associated Disorder (WAD) grading, the Neck Disability Index (NDI) and a Visual Analogue Scale (VAS) for pain were recommended by the PIC for use and inclusion in every soft-tissue (‘whiplash’) examination and medical report. The approach aims to bring more consistency to the examination, medical reporting and diagnosis of soft-tissue injuries. The PIC’s recommendation was unanimously agreed by its members which included medical, legal and insurance company representatives. When all of these stakeholders adopt the same template, reports for the same injuries but prepared after examinations at different times will allow for comparative analysis of the injuries over time.
Further versions and improvements to the Injuries Resolution Board Medical Assessment Form are expected. The Injuries Resolution Board will communicate with medical practitioners on developments. Medical practitioners should contact their medical software providers in terms of having the Form integrated into their software applications. In some software applications the ‘reply attachments’ functionality can assist with integrating, e.g. the separately completed Neck Disability Index (NDI), into the body of the main medical report.
It is preferable that such requests should be referred to the Injuries Resolution Board in the first instance. Data protection considerations will apply.
The reasonable cost of physiotherapy treatment required as a result of the injuries which are the subject of the claim is recoverable as part of the claimants Special damages.
Yes.
Yes.